Family farms in Virginia and all
across the United States face numerous challenges these days, including
the controversial issue of animal welfare vs. animal rights. Farmers and
agribusiness representatives I talk with say the topic is possibly one of
the most significant challenges facing current and future generations of
agriculturists. Not only do Virginia farmers have to deal with the
dramatically higher cost of fuel to operate tractors and other equipment
(fuel prices doubling since 2003); and not only do Virginia farmers have
to be concerned about having access to affordable land for raising crops
and livestock (farm real estate values in Virginia increased 29 percent
from 2005 to 2006 according to a recent USDA report); but often, farmers
have to worry about some group of wild-haired, idealistic demonstrators at
the end of the farm lane waving signs that proclaim, �Cows have rights
too!�
Make no mistake about it, the
animal-rights agenda has ratcheted up in the last decade. After focusing
on the scientific research community for many years, animal-rights
activists have gradually shifted their focus to commercial animal
agriculture and the food industry. Some activists may identify themselves
as members of animal-welfare organizations, but are often involved in
establishing human rights for animals.
You might ask �So what�s the
difference between animal rights and animal welfare?� Ahhhh, a very
important question! It is vitally important to understand the dramatic
difference between the two positions.
Animal-rights supporters reject all
animal use, no matter how humane. Probably the most famous of these groups
is Virginia-based People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA). A
visitor to the PETA Web site will see the following statement on the front
page: �PETA believes that animals have rights and deserve to have their
best interests taken into consideration, regardless of whether they are
useful to humans. Like you, they are capable of suffering and have an
interest in leading their own lives; therefore, they are not ours to use
� for food, clothing, entertainment, experimentation, or any other
reason.�
Animal-rights groups such as PETA
loudly proclaim the purpose of their activism is to protect non-human
animals from being exploited by people. Most of us (people, that is)
consider it a radical movement, primarily because it evokes a
philosophical (and political) belief that animals have inherent rights
equivalent to those of human beings.
The animal-welfare viewpoint, however,
is remarkably different from the animal-rights agenda. It encourages the
responsible use of animals to satisfy basic human needs, including
companionship, food, clothing and medical research.
The American Veterinary Medical
Association defines animal welfare as �a human responsibility� to
assure that the basic needs of animals are met. Most Virginia farmers
agree with this position, believing their dominion over food animals
brings with it the responsibility to treat them with respect and
consideration. They accept that it is their responsibility to provide
clean water, nutritious feed, and an acceptable living environment for
animals raised on their farms.
A frequent speaker at educational
events on livestock production in Virginia is Dr. Temple Grandin,
professor of Animal Science at Colorado State University. Dr. Grandin says
treating farm animals in a humane manner is the right thing to do. In one
of her visits, I distinctly remember her counseling farmers about future
conflicts. �The public is becoming increasingly concerned about how
animals are treated,� warned Grandin. She said her observations, made at
several hundred farms, ranches, feedlots, and slaughter plants, indicate
that the single most important factor that affects animal welfare is the
attitude of management. �Places (farms) that have good animal welfare
have a manager who cares. Places where animal welfare is poor often have a
manager who does not care,� said Grandin. She advised all Virginia
farmers to be good managers and good practitioners of animal welfare.
So what are farmers to do about the
animal-rights crowd? Perhaps they should heed the advice of Kay N.
Johnson, executive vice president of another Virginia-based organization
involved in animal issues. Johnson recently told reporters, �We know
animal-rights activists are never going to go away. Their goal, many of
them, is to create a vegan or vegetarian society.� She said this will
probably never happen in the United States, but �their actions can have
an impact on the market and on business operations.� Johnson also said
farmers and others involved in commercial animal production have a
responsibility to speak out on animal-welfare issues, �rather than
having activists define what we do and how animals are cared for.� Amen,
Ms. Johnson!
Jeff Ishee is host and producer of the
award-winning programs On the Farm radio and Virginia Farming, a
production of Virginia Public Television. He resides in Augusta County.